RideScout

Ride1Up Prodigy V2 vs Urtopia Carbon Classic Step-Thru

Two commuter e-bikes at $1,999–$2,395, every published spec lined up. Nothing here is estimated: a figure the manufacturer does not publish is shown as “—”.

vs

Where they differ

  • The Prodigy V2 makes 45 Nm more torque.
  • The Prodigy V2 peaks 450 W higher.
  • The Carbon Classic Step-Thru claims 22 more miles of range.
  • The Prodigy V2 carries 151 Wh more battery.
  • The Carbon Classic Step-Thru is 17 lb lighter.
  • The Prodigy V2 carries 60 lb more total load.
  • The Carbon Classic Step-Thru costs $396 less.
  • The Prodigy V2 assists 3 mph faster.
  • The Prodigy V2 is mid-drive; the Carbon Classic Step-Thru is rear hub.
  • The Prodigy V2 ships as class 3; the Carbon Classic Step-Thru ships as class 2.

Every spec, side by side

Prodigy V2Carbon Classic Step-Thru
Headline
Price$2,395$1,999
CategoryCommuterCommuter
Price per Wh$4.75 per Wh$5.66 per Wh
Model year20262026
Motor
Torque90 Nm45 Nm
Motor power250 W350 W
Peak power950 W500 W
DriveMid-driveRear hub
Motor makeBrose TF SprinterUrtopia
SensorTorqueTorque
Battery & range
Battery504 Wh353 Wh
Voltage36V36V
Capacity14 Ah9.8 Ah
CellsSamsungSamsung
Removable batteryYes
Range (claim)50 mi72 mi
Range as stated30-50 milesUp to 72 mi (180 lb rider, ECO, flat, no throttle)
Est. real range32 mi22 mi
Estimate assumes16 Wh per mile16 Wh per mile
Weight & capacity
Weight58 lb41 lb
Max load300 lb240 lb
Rack capacity40 lb
Class & speed
Ships asClass 3: pedal assist to 28 mphClass 2: throttle, assist to 20 mph
Unlocks toClass 3Class 2
ClassClass 3Class 2
ThrottleYes
Top assisted speed28 mph25 mph
Build
Gears9-speed8-speed
DrivetrainMicroShift 9-speed (chain) or Enviolo CVT + Gates beltShimano
BrakesHydraulic discHydraulic disc
Front rotor180 mm160 mm
Rear rotor180 mm160 mm
SuspensionHardtail (front only)
Fork travel100 mm
Rear travelNoneNone
Front suspensionYes
Suspension seatpostNoNo
Tires27.5 x 2.25Kenda 700 x 40c
DisplayBrose 1.5" color LCD3.5" colour LCD
FrameAlloyToray carbon fibre
SizesST, XRS, M, L
Step-through optionYesYes
Included
LightsYesYes
FendersYes
RackYes
SafetyUL 2849*UL 2271
Safety certificationUL 2849: most models, confirm this oneUL 2271: battery only
As the maker states itTUV ANSI/CAN/UL 2849 & 2271 compliant, certified through TUV for most of their inventoryBattery UL 2271 Certified (Classic also EN 50604)
Warranty1 yr2 yr
Warranty terms1-Year Warranty against manufacturing defects2-Year Warranty (brand policy)

Specs transcribed from ride1up.com on 2026-09-19 and newurtopia.com on 2026-09-20. Manufacturers revise specs without notice: confirm before buying.

Add a third bike to this comparison